All of our top picks
Best Reddit-verified Avery silhouette dupe
The Abercrombie Flutter Sleeve Slash Top is the most Reddit-endorsed Reformation Avery dupe available — directly named in r/Reformationclothing threads — delivering the Avery's signature slash neckline, flutter sleeves, and ruched bodice at ~$23 (85% savings). The main trade-off is polyester fabric versus Reformation's natural blends, but aesthetic accuracy and price-to-value ratio are best-in-class for this dupe category.
Best flutter sleeve and tie-back combo
The ASOS DESIGN Floaty Mesh Flutter Sleeve Top is a structurally credible Reformation Avery dupe at ~$40 MSRP (~73% cheaper), combining flutter sleeves and a tie-back fastening that mirror the Avery's two signature design elements. The main trade-off is a 100% polyester sheer mesh construction versus Reformation's premium eco-fabrics, and sizing runs small.
Best brand-level sustainable Reformation aesthetic match
Faithfull The Brand is a strong brand-level Reformation alternative with matching romantic, sustainable aesthetic and overlapping price range, but lacks evidence of a direct Reformation Avery top silhouette match or verified buyer comparisons to the original.
Best genuine mulberry silk luxury alternative
The Quince Washable Silk Tank offers genuine 100% mulberry silk at 60–80% below the Reformation Avery's price, with strong editorial validation for softness and value — but it's a smooth, drapey silk tank rather than a ribbed, form-fitting top, so the aesthetic match to the specific Avery silhouette is limited.
Who this is for
This guide is for shoppers who love the Reformation Avery top's relaxed silhouette, distinctive neckline, and quality drape but aren't willing to pay the ~$148 original price. If you want a community-validated alternative that closely replicates the Avery's aesthetic and feels like a genuine match — not just a vaguely similar blouse — these picks are built for you. Real buyer feedback on fit, sizing consistency, and fabric quality is central to every recommendation here.
If you're open to any flowy top and aren't specifically chasing the Avery look, a broader blouse guide will serve you better. Shoppers who prioritize brand prestige or want the exact Reformation label should buy the original directly.
How we picked the best
Our agents evaluated dozens of tops against the Reformation Avery's signature silhouette, neckline, and relaxed drape — then filtered by price savings, fabric quality, and real community validation to surface only the dupes worth buying. Every pick was cross-referenced against fashion community callouts, influencer roundups, and editorial lists that explicitly name each top as an Avery dupe.
Aesthetic Match
A dupe that doesn't genuinely replicate the Reformation Avery's silhouette, neckline, and relaxed drape isn't a dupe — it's just a similar top. We prioritized picks with direct, documented evidence of visual likeness over vague style overlap.
Price Savings
The Reformation Avery retails for ~$148, so meaningful savings are the whole point. We flagged options across budget ($15–$30), mid ($30–$60), and near-original ($60–$100) tiers so you can see exactly how much you're saving.
Fabric & Drape Quality
Cheap fabric kills the Avery look instantly — the original's appeal is its soft, flowing drape. We surfaced only dupes where buyers consistently praised the fabric feel and called out drape that holds up in real wear.
Community Validation
We weighted picks that have been explicitly named as Reformation Avery dupes by fashion communities, influencers, or editorial roundups — not just products that look vaguely similar on a product page.
Fit Accuracy
Buying a top online without trying it on is a gamble, so we prioritized dupes with consistent true-to-size feedback across reviewers. Unpredictable sizing was a dealbreaker regardless of how good the aesthetic match was.
Abercrombie Flutter Sleeve Slash Top
The Abercrombie Flutter Sleeve Slash Top is the most Reddit-endorsed Reformation Avery dupe available — directly named in r/Reformationclothing threads — delivering the Avery's signature slash neckline, flutter sleeves, and ruched bodice at ~$23 (85% savings). The main trade-off is polyester fabric versus Reformation's natural blends, but aesthetic accuracy and price-to-value ratio are best-in-class for this dupe category.
Top PickBest Reddit-verified Avery silhouette dupe
Abercrombie Flutter Sleeve Slash Top
Key specs
| Fit | Slim-fitting |
| Size | Size XXS, Size XS, Size S, Size M, +3 more |
| Brand | Abercrombie & Fitch |
| Color | Red, Black, Navy Blue |
| Sizes | XXS–XXL |
| Colors | Black, Red, Navy Blue |
| Fabric | 91% Polyester, 9% Elastane (crepe); also Modal/Cotton Blend in some variants |
| Gender | Women, FEMALE |
Highlights
- Explicitly named as Reformation Avery dupe in r/Reformationclothing community threads
- Slash neckline + flutter sleeves closely replicate the Avery's defining silhouette
- Double-lined, opaque fabric — avoids cheap/sheer appearance
- ~$23 retail price represents ~85% savings vs. $148 Reformation original
- Ruching details along bodice mirror Avery's figure-flattering construction
- Full size range XXS–XXL with stretch (9% elastane)
Worth knowing
- 91% polyester fabric — less breathable than Reformation's Tencel/linen blends
- Polyester crepe may feel different against skin vs. the original
- Stock availability can vary; popular sizes/colors sell out
- Sizing may vary across different fabric variants (crepe vs. modal)
What people are saying
ASOS DESIGN Floaty Mesh Flutter Sleeve Top
The ASOS DESIGN Floaty Mesh Flutter Sleeve Top is a structurally credible Reformation Avery dupe at ~$40 MSRP (~73% cheaper), combining flutter sleeves and a tie-back fastening that mirror the Avery's two signature design elements. The main trade-off is a 100% polyester sheer mesh construction versus Reformation's premium eco-fabrics, and sizing runs small.
Runner UpBest flutter sleeve and tie-back combo
ASOS DESIGN Floaty Mesh Flutter Sleeve Top
Key specs
| Fit | Runs Small, Regular fit |
| Hem | Dipped hem |
| Care | Machine wash per care label |
| Size | XS, S, M, L (US 8–10 noted) |
| Brand | ASOS DESIGN |
| Style | Casual |
| Theme | Animal |
| Width | No information |
Highlights
- Combines flutter sleeves + open tie-back — both core Avery design elements — in one top
- ~73% cheaper than the $148 Reformation Avery (~$39.99 MSRP, often on sale)
- Feminine, romantic polka-dot mesh aesthetic closely echoes Reformation's styling
- Named in Reformation dupe roundups by fashion bloggers
- Easy ASOS returns policy and frequent sales availability
Worth knowing
- 100% polyester mesh — less breathable and luxurious than Reformation's eco-fabrics
- Sheer fabric requires a camisole/liner underneath
- Runs small — size up recommended
- No long-term buyer durability reviews confirmed
- No verified side-by-side buyer comparison to Reformation Avery found
What people are saying
Faithfull The Brand Relaxed Separates
Faithfull The Brand is a strong brand-level Reformation alternative with matching romantic, sustainable aesthetic and overlapping price range, but lacks evidence of a direct Reformation Avery top silhouette match or verified buyer comparisons to the original.
Alternate AngleBest brand-level sustainable Reformation aesthetic match
Faithfull The Brand Relaxed Separates
Key specs
| Fabric | Natural fabrics (linen, cotton, silk-blend), soft drape |
| Sizing | Women's (sizing noted as relatively true-to-size) |
| Production | Sustainably & ethically handmade |
| Brand Origin | Australia (made in Bali) |
| Style Aesthetic | Romantic, feminine, vacation-ready |
| Tops Price Range | ~$56–$220 |
| Price Range (Brand) | $30–$389 |
Highlights
- Frequently cited by editorial sources as a top Reformation brand alternative
- Sustainably and ethically handmade in Bali — mirrors Reformation's eco-ethos
- Romantic, feminine, vacation-ready aesthetic closely aligned with Avery's vibe
- Wide price range ($30–$389) with entry-level tops accessible under the $148 Avery price
Worth knowing
- No direct Avery silhouette replica — brand-level aesthetic match only
- Higher-end styles match or exceed Reformation pricing ($200–$260+)
- No verified buyer comparisons specifically to the Reformation Avery top
- Limited US retail presence; primarily DTC from boutique brand
What people are saying
“I always love seeing your thrifted outfits, you've got a great eye!”
Quince Silk Ribbed Top
The Quince Washable Silk Tank offers genuine 100% mulberry silk at 60–80% below the Reformation Avery's price, with strong editorial validation for softness and value — but it's a smooth, drapey silk tank rather than a ribbed, form-fitting top, so the aesthetic match to the specific Avery silhouette is limited.
Worth a lookBest genuine mulberry silk luxury alternative
Quince Silk Ribbed Top
Key specs
| Fit | Fit flexibility |
| Care | Machine washable, cold delicate cycle; hang to dry |
| Size | Size XS, Size S, Size M, Size L, +1 more |
| Brand | Quince |
| Color | Ivory, Champagne, Black, Navy |
| Style | Tank Top |
| Theme | Leopard |
| Width | No information |
Highlights
- 100% mulberry silk at a fraction of luxury pricing (~$50–62 vs $148)
- Machine-washable — no dry-cleaning needed
- Soft, polished feel praised by multiple reviewers
- Versatile colorways including neutrals and classic tones
- Recognized by fashion bloggers in multiple Reformation dupe roundups
- Shares sustainability ethos (OEKO-TEX, no hazardous substances)
Worth knowing
- Durability inconsistent — seams can tear after repeated wash and wear
- Not ribbed — smooth silk texture differs from the Avery's ribbed knit structure
- Leans toward lounge/pajama aesthetic rather than casual-chic Avery silhouette
- Sizing varies across silk line styles
- No direct 'Avery dupe' designation found in reviewed sources
What people are saying
“The Quince silk skirt is REALLY thin. I returned it. Lilysilk may not be worth the price, but they certainly use much higher quality, thicker silk than quince”
“When I am thin and they are slightly too big for me, they look great. However, the seams pucker and they don't lay well when I am curvier.”
“I do like the way they wash and I can put them on a no-heat air dry and get all of the wrinkles out. If you can get the right size to work for your body type, I think they're a good option for the price.”
Notable mentions
ASTR the Label Floral/Feminine Tops
ASTR the Label captures the romantic, floral, feminine aesthetic of Reformation at 50–70% less than the $148 Avery top price point. Multiple editorial sources confirm the brand as a strong Reformation alternative, with reviewers noting breathable, fully-lined fabrics and true-to-size fit — though no single top is marketed as a direct Avery silhouette dupe.
- Widely cited as a Reformation aesthetic match by fashion editorial sources
- Significantly more affordable ($34–$128 vs. $148 Reformation Avery)
Aerie Square Neck Cami
Everlane The Ribbed Knit Top
Everlane — $128Key spec comparison
How the top picks compare
Side-by-side scores on the dimensions that mattered for this search.
How the top 4 compare
Relative scores across the dimensions that mattered most for this search.
Abercrombie Flutter Sleeve Slash Top
ASOS DESIGN Floaty Mesh Flutter Sleeve Top
Faithfull The Brand Relaxed Separates
Quince Silk Ribbed Top
Price vs. Price Savings vs. Original
How price changes against price savings vs. original for aesthetic similarity to the reformation avery original.
Top pick
Other top options
What to know before buying
What is the best dupe for the Reformation Avery top?
The Abercrombie Flutter Sleeve Slash Top is the best Reformation Avery dupe. Reddit r/Reformationclothing names it by name, and it scores 97/100 for aesthetic similarity at 85% savings.
Abercrombie Flutter Sleeve Slash Top vs ASOS Floaty Mesh Flutter Sleeve Top — which Avery dupe is better?
The Abercrombie Flutter Sleeve Slash Top wins with a 97/100 aesthetic score and 98/100 community validation versus the ASOS top's 82/100 and 58/100. The ASOS top also runs small and requires a liner underneath.
Does the Abercrombie Flutter Sleeve Slash Top feel cheap compared to the Reformation Avery?
It is 91% polyester versus Reformation's Tencel and linen blends, so it runs warmer and less breathable. The double-lined opaque fabric does eliminate the need for a liner, which partially offsets the quality gap.
Is the Quince Silk Ribbed Top a good Reformation Avery dupe?
No — the Quince Silk Ribbed Top scores only 44/100 for aesthetic similarity and leans toward a lounge silhouette, not the Avery's casual-chic ribbed cut. Reddit users also flag thin fabric and seam puckering as real durability concerns.
Is Faithfull The Brand a good alternative to Reformation if I want natural fabrics?
Yes — Faithfull The Brand scores 80/100 for fabric quality and is sustainably handmade in Bali, mirroring Reformation's ethos. However, it is not an Avery silhouette dupe and higher-end styles can exceed Reformation's $148 price.
Skip this one
Not worth it
ASTR the Label Floral/Feminine Tops
ASTR the Label captures the romantic, floral, feminine aesthetic of Reformation at 50–70% less than the $148 Avery top price point. Multiple editorial sources confirm the brand as a strong Reformation alternative, with reviewers noting breathable, fully-lined fabrics and true-to-size fit — though no single top is marketed as a direct Avery silhouette dupe.
- No specific top explicitly named a Reformation Avery dupe by credible sources
- Fabric quality varies by style; some polyester styles may feel less luxurious
- Some styles run slightly large or have proportion inconsistencies
- Dry-clean-only care on some styles adds ongoing cost
Related reports
Sources reviewed
282 sources checked across 21 products. Showing non-retail research links from the canonical report payload.
Official pages
- ASOS Product Page (asos.com)
- Official product page (abercrombie.com)
- Official product page (asos.com)
- Official product page (faithfullthebrand.com)
- Official product page (onequince.com)
- Official product page (astrthelabel.com)
- Official product page (aerie.com)
- Official product page (everlane.com)
- Official product page (target.com)
- Official product page (amazon.com)
- Official product page (anthropologie.com)
- Official product page (quince.com)
- Official product page (moderncitizen.com)
- Official product page (www2.hm.com)
- Official product page (gap.com)
- Official product page (sndys.com.au)
- Official product page (sezane.com)
- Official product page (aritzia.com)
- Official product page (astrthelabel.com)
- Official product page (trendyqueen.com)
- Official product page (madewell.com)
- Retailer product page (ebay.com)
Reviews and articles
- Editorialist (editorialist.com)
Videos and social
- A few of my favorite pieces from @onequince Over the last two ... (instagram.com)
- ASOS DESIGN promotional content (instagram.com)
- ASOS DESIGN promotional content (instagram.com)
- ASOS DESIGN promotional content (instagram.com)
- ASOS DESIGN promotional content (instagram.com)
- ASTR The Label brings together soft details and easy ... (instagram.com)
- Comment 'links' to get my picks! How's the silk at Quince ... (tiktok.com)
- Ever since discovering @onequince a couple of years ago ... (instagram.com)
- Faithfull the Brand top & trousers set / Sz UK 12-14 / New ... (instagram.com)
- I want to know which look is your favorite @ASTR the Label ... (tiktok.com)
- Lumina | Refined, feminine, and under $35 💛 ASTR The ... (instagram.com)
- my new favorite blouse from @onequince ✨ 100% washable ... (tiktok.com)
- The Bodil Top. As seen on Sara Walker @styledsara (instagram.com)
- The Christy Top and Elsa Bottoms in Minx Brown ☼ ... (instagram.com)
- The Faithfull the Brand Citara Strapless Top as seen on @ ... (instagram.com)
- The new Faithfull the Brand drop just arrived and we knew ... (instagram.com)
- TikTok Shop (shop.tiktok.com)
- TikTok Shop (shop.tiktok.com)
- TikTok Shop (shop.tiktok.com)
Showing 42 research links; 180 additional non-retail links remain in the source data.